Ken
Burns Prohibition: Olmstead Do you have an expectation of
privacy in electronic communications? Olmstead
1928: No. Katz 1967: Yes. ECPA 1986: Yes. Facebook
2011: M'eh??
In
a Time When Email Costs 26c and Takes Two Days
to Deliver The USPS is rumored to be running
ads attacking email, attempting to install fear in
the public that email is "insecure." This is not
the first time the USPS felt threatened by email.
In the late 1970s the USPS attempted to solved the
email problem by suggestion that there ought to be
a law against it.
In
Which We Learn the Difference Between "Being
Slow" and "Bad Faith"
A guy becomes a real estate franchisee and sets up
some websites. But then the franchisee agreement
lapses. Those websites with the plaintiff's
trademark pointed to the guy's new real estate
website. Was he just slow to take down his old
website, or was it "bad faith"?
In
Which We Learn Whether a Sour Relationship
Constitutes a Breach of Contract or a
Violation of the AntiCybersquatting Consumer
Protect Act
So a guy hirers a web designer to build a web
site, which the web designer does. And everything
is good, until, of course, the relationship
between the guy and the web designer "sours."
And the web designer says, "okay, pay me what you
owe me, and I will turn over the website and the
domain name to you." Pop Quiz: Did the web
designer just violate the Anti Cybersquatting
Consumer Protect Act? No really, that's a serious
question.
The
Wayward AntCybersquatter Consumer Protection
Act
The Anti-Cybersquatting Consumer Protection Act
(ACPA) has lost its way. The ACPA was passed in an
era of domain name land grabs, where nefarious
individuals would register and warehouse oodles of
valuable domain names, and then extract ransom
from bewildered-trademark owners. These nefarious
individuals are known as " cybersquatters ",
and, according to the ACPA
, they are bad.
The
Threat From Within
The security vendor-phobe at the head of the
conference bangs on the podium with his shoe
declaring that "The greatest threat comes from
within! (buy our product for your network's
salvation)."
Cybersquatting
Bad!
The first of a series of posts on the Anti
Cybersquatting Consumer Protection Act, starting
with a review of the ACPA's legislative history.
"On-line extortion in any form is unacceptable and
outrageous. Whether it's people extorting
companies by registering company names,
misdirecting Internet users to inappropriate
sites, or otherwise attempting to damage a
trademark that a business has spent decades
building into a recognizable brand, anyone
engaging in cyber-squatting activity should be
held accountable for their actions." --Sen.
Abraham, Sponsor of the ACPA
In
Which We Learn the Cost of Letting a Domain
Name Expire During a Litigation
If you let a domain name expire during a pending
Anti Cybersquatter Consumer Protection Act case,
and are ordered to transfer that domain name to
plaintiff, is now impossible for you to transfer
the expired domain name? Apparently not.
October is CyberSecurity
Month
"National
Cyber Security Awareness Month (NCSAM),
conducted every October since 2004, is a national
public awareness campaign to encourage everyone to
protect their computers and our nation's critical
cyber infrastructure. Cyber security requires
vigilance 365 days per year. However, the
Department of Homeland Security (DHS), the
National Cyber Security Alliance (NCSA), and the
Multi-State Information Sharing and Analysis
Center (MS-ISAC), the primary drivers of NCSAM,
coordinate to shed a brighter light in October on
what home users, schools, businesses and
governments need to do in order to protect their
computers, children, and data." See CT's information
on Cybersecurity.
WHOIS
Dat who say WHOIS Dat when I say WHOIS Dat?
Using WHOIS a discovery technique to discover who
is messing with you, and learning the subpoena's
used in limited discovery generally wont get you
full server logs.
ReTweet
ReLawsuit?
If Joe comes to my Web 2.0 site and posts a
defamatory comment about Jane, I am not a
publisher of that comment pursuant to Sec. 230
even though it is on my site, and therefore am not
liable. But what happens if I retweet Joe's
comment?
A
Hack. A Scrape. A Crash. A Lawsuit. Snap-On
Business Solutions, Inc., v O'Neil Associates,
Inc., (ND Ohio April 16, 2010)
In today's
story , we hear a tale of a business deal
gone sour, the alleged hacking and crashing of a
computer system, data that are free except when
it's not, and words that don't always mean what
they appear to mean. Can Daffy's access to a
database be unauthorized if Thurston controls who
has access, and Thurston gave Daffy permission to
access? Does Thurston violate copyright law when
the data in the database is his, and he makes a
copy of it? This sounds like a case for Motion-to-Dismiss-Man
and his somewhat incredible superpowers!
1910
Navy Radio Station in Arlington, VA
This short history story comes from Arlington
Virginia, home town of the 1910 US Navy
Radio station. Back in the day, before broadcast
radio - before the Federal Communications
Commission - heck even before the Federal
Radio Commission -- folk were interested
in "wireless" as a means for ship-to-shore
communications. Marconi
monopolized commercial wireless telegraph
service to shipping - while the US Navy took
interest in the ability to communicate with the
fleet at sea. The first federal agency to exercise
regulatory spectrum authority was in fact not the
FCC but the US
Navy . Anyway, on with this great story....
Virtual
Banishment and the First Amendment: Estavillo
v. Sony Computer Entertainment of America
Many of us host or sponsor online communities of
one form or another. On occasion, this means we
must engage in moderation of the discourse in that
community, and, as chance may arise, on occasion,
we must give some chap the boot from the community
for violating the AUP or the TOS. Inevitable, the
booted chap screams "First Amendment Violation,"
to which we must respond, "The First Amendment
restrains government actors - we are not
government actors." Apparently, we are correct.
Join the Cybertelecom-l
online discussion, or
Subscribe to the Cybertelecom
News, a daily
newsletter filled with the latest news,
notices, and pronouncements.
Speaking of Cyber Security,
OnGuard Online has just released its new guide NetCetera:
Talking to Kids About Online Safety.
"In Net Cetera: Chatting With Kids About Being
Online, OnGuard Online gives adults practical tips
to help kids navigate the online world. Kids and
parents have many ways of socializing and
communicating online, but they come with certain
risks. This guide encourages parents to reduce the
risks by talking to kids about how they
communicate - online and off - and helping kids
engage in conduct they can be proud of. Net Cetera
covers what parents need to know, where to go for
more information, and issues to raise with kids
about living their lives online."
"Steal
More WiFi!",
Cybertelecom Research Paper #8, v 0.9 (Discussion
Draft) (released Jan. 26, 2009)
There has arisen a small
litany of criminal prosecutions of nefarious
dudes in long black trench coats that congregate
outside coffee houses with their laptops, piggy
backing on open WiFi networks in order to play
World of Warcraft. The way in which these cases
have unfolded demonstrates discomfort within the
courts and amongst the public concerning the
handling of these perpetrators. . . . .
In
Which We (Once Again) Consider: Is it Legal to
Link? Plaintiff Voldemort demands
that Blockshopper, a real estate news site, stop
linking to Plaintiff - and objects to the mere
mention of Plaintiff's name. Better do as
Voldemort says! Dont link to plaintiff and dont
mention plaintiff's name!
In
Which We Explore the Federal Laws that Apply
to Cyberstalking
Cyberstalking is a tragedy to which current law
responds poorly. The solution is (A) rewrite
local law in order to cover the Internet, (B)
attempt to jam an unfortunate event into a law
that was not designed to cover the event, or (C)
look to enforcement of annoying federal laws?
Fortunately, the feds have some clear advice for
us on this matter.
History Teaches Us Nothing: If
there is one thing we learn from history,
it is that we learn nothing from history!
I love communications history. So frequently
with our narrow vision of the present we presume
that we are in an era of innovation and
dramatically new paradigms - when so much of
what is, already has been. I stumbled upon a
wonderful government history, Captain Linwood S.
Howeth, USN (Retired), History of
Communications-Electronics in the United
States Navy, Bureau of Ships and Office
of Naval History (1963) (Govt
Work: public
domain), which talks about such
things as Marconi refusing to deliver messages
because the transmitting radio station was not
using Marconi radio equipment. Hum, where I have
I heard of that problem before. Select
portions of this text have been uploaded
to the history section.
Steal
More Wifi, part 2!
Charlie the Unicorn pulls up to parking lot of
the local coffee house driving his convertible
Mustang (what else would he be driving). He
opens his laptop, finds an open WiFi network,
and searches eBay in the hopes of finding that
new kidney that he so desperately needs. Pop
quiz: What law has Charlie broken?
NSFNET:
The Partnership that Changed the World On November 29 &
30, in Washington DC was an NSFNET
Celebration. It was an oral history
project. Almost all of the primary people from the
primary organizations (NSF, MERIT, IBM, MCI) were
present, retelling the NSFNET Story. I was
fascinated. It is, like so many things, like
looking a picture in black and white, and then
seeing the same picture in color. So much was
added to my understanding of the history. Things
like - the "network of network?" - that was
NSFNET. NSFNET established the network hierarchy
and "tiers." The roots of NSF's use of
"cooperative agreements" and how that created the
foundation of future policy struggles. This was
not, after all, a simple R&D and transfer of
technology project that NSF funded. This was, as
the NSFNET Final Report stated, communications
infrastructure, vital to the success of our
economy and culture. At any rate, all this led to
significant revisions to CT's history section.
Take a look; give feedback!
See CT News Page for RSS Feeds, Twitter, Delicious
"A people who mean to
be their own governors must arm
themselves with the power that knowledge
gives. A popular government without
popular knowledge or the means of
acquiring it is but a prelude to a farce
or a tragedy or perhaps both." -James
Madison
The hope of a secure
and livable world lies with disciplined
nonconformists who are dedicated to
justice, peace and brotherhood. --
Martin
Luther King, Jr.
Cybertelecom
is an educational project; it does not offer
legal advice. Dont ask for it;
inquiries seeking legal advice will
not be responded to.